| Family |
Minnie Ann Cogswell, b. 27 Aug 1866, Tekonsha, Calhoun, Michigan, USA , d. 7 Sep 1944, Lodi, San Joaquin, California, USA (Age 78 years) |
| Children |
| | 1. William Raymond Appling, b. 8 Nov 1889, Stanislaus, California, USA [natural] |
| | 2. Hugh Lester Appling, b. 2 Jan 1892, Stanislaus, California, USA [natural] |
| | 3. Chandley Elmer Appling, b. 20 Sep 1894, Stanislaus, California, USA [natural] |
| | 4. Clara Ellen Appling, b. 9 Mar 1897, Stanislaus, California, USA [natural] |
| | 5. Edward Gratton Appling, b. 15 Jun 1901, Stanislaus, California, USA [natural] |
| | 6. Lillian Minnie Appling, b. 9 Jun 1903, Stanislaus, California, USA [natural] |
|